Jul 11, 2018

Okay, so the top 12 finalist for American Idol Season 3 have been chosen by you, me, the judges and the rest of America. Sindy and I think it's a pretty good group. And so we're giving ya our faves - ranking the entire 12 - from least fave (#12) to absolute fave (#1). Here goes...

Simon's American Idol Contestant Rankings 4m5e2m

#12 Amy Adams 2o106o

I think Amy will be the first voted off. I don't like her voice and was surprised she made it this far.

#11 Jon Peter Lewis 176p1z

Jon Peter is a cool guy, but he just doesn't cut it vocally. It's too bad.

#10 George Huff 5z2l20

George is way too happy-go-lucky and way too shakey on the vocals. He kinda irks me.

#9 Jasmine Trias 1o312w

Jasmine is pretty good vocally, but she doesn't really have a lot of, as Simon Cowell would say, "It factor."

#8 Leah Labelle 1a152x

Leah is a really great singer - sometimes. I don't think she's solid enough.

#7 Jennifer Hudson j6y45

Jen's a cool girl, but she makes goofy faces when she sings - it makes me laugh.

#6 John Stevens 132o2i

The guy can rock it old-school pretty large. But this is not Old-School American Idol, ya know?

#5 Matthew Rogers 6fbj

He's got stage presence and charm - and his pipes aren't bad either.

#4 Camile Velasco 5143z

Like Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson said, Camile is Lauren Hill-ish. I dig Lauren Hill. .

#3 Diana DeGarmo b3l1a

Diana's totally cute and man, does she have a great voice. I like her a lot.

#2 La Toya London 706x6s

La Toya's song had me rockin'. She's cute too.

Simon's #1 Favorite American Idol Contestant: 22b4d

Fantasia Barrino 6h5h2i

Fantasia's my fave out of the Top 12 finalists because she's the whole package. She's got an amazing voice like La Toya London and Diana DeGarmo, but on top of that Fantasia's cute and full of personality. She's my favorite American Idol season 3 contestant.

Click here to find out Sindy's fave contestant on American Idol season 3.
Do ya agree with Simon's picks? Or do ya have some opinions of your own you wanna share? Head on over to our special American Idol section and have your say!